Picture this. You’re asking your AI assistant about the tide times for a fishing trip, and it casually drops a line about your Capital One balance. Except it’s not your balance. It’s somebody else’s. That’s not a hypothetical, that’s what Meta Muse did to one of Meta’s own employees, according to internal posts seen by Reuters and summed up by TechCrunch.
Muse, if you’ve managed to avoid the ads, is Meta’s agent that’s supposed to run your digital life: answer emails, book things, buy things. It launched in September and already sits above 10 million downloads. And right now the people testing it inside Meta are the ones sounding the alarm.
Meta Muse and the wrong person’s data
The list of weirdness is long. Employees reported Muse surfacing childcare requests they never made, career advice they never asked for, product orders they never placed, and that famous message: “BTW, two bank updates, your Capital One balance is $2722.58, your Charles Schwab balance is $5899.57.” In a chat about the weather. It also allegedly booked a non-refundable Airbnb nobody asked for and quoted wrong prices on real purchases.
Meta’s explanation is that these are “hallucinations”, now fixed, and that employees run internal builds the public doesn’t get. A member of the Superintelligence team put it more candidly in an internal thread: the agent seems to invent follow-up messages when it’s nudged to re-engage users between sessions, and “unfortunately, these hallucinations tend to be about the most embarrassing topics, like finances, IT security or personal safety”.
Hallucinated or leaked, it doesn’t matter much to the person reading it. If I can’t tell whether my assistant is quoting my bank or making up a number, the product is useless for exactly the tasks it’s sold for. Airlines figured that out early, which is why United simply banned AI agents from booking flights rather than deal with the fallout.
The Signal problem
The second story is the one that bugs me more, because it isn’t a hallucination. One employee got a reminder from Muse to answer her sister on Signal, an app she had never connected to the agent. “This seems like an extreme privacy violation. I definitely did not grant it access to other apps,” she wrote.
Reuters reproduced it with help from Signal and the AI Now Institute. On Android, Muse skips Meta’s own Connector tool and uses permissions granted during setup to read the content of Signal notifications. On macOS, it combines accessibility settings with screen capture to scrape the messages. Apple’s response was dry: accessibility tools are for people with disabilities, and using them for anything else “can put personal data at risk”.
Meta’s line is that Muse requires explicit consent before touching another app. Technically true, maybe. But “you clicked allow on a notification permission three weeks ago” is not what most people mean by consent, and Meta of all companies knows the difference.
Signal wants a robots.txt for apps
Meredith Whittaker, Signal’s president, accused Meta of shipping Muse “without the slightest regard for basic privacy and cybersecurity principles”, and asked for a standard way for developers to tell AI agents to stay out of their apps. Basically a robots.txt for applications, which is exactly where the web ended up with crawlers, and the one-line AI training signal publishers now use.
I’d take that deal. Agents that act on your behalf are coming whether we like it or not, and the sane model is opt-in per app, enforced by the OS, not “the agent found a side door through the notification shade”. Until that exists, the burden lands on you, the same way banks are already making you liable for whatever your agent does.
So here’s my practical advice, boring as it is: if you installed Muse, go through its Android permissions and macOS accessibility and screen recording grants, and strip everything it doesn’t strictly need. And keep anything you’d be embarrassed to see quoted in a weather chat well away from it.
Ten million people gave Meta an agent with the keys to their phone. Meta’s own staff are the ones asking for them back.
Discover more from TechPassion
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.




